Proton is calling staff in for interviews about AI — and their jobs may be at stake
Proton, the Swiss company known for encrypted email and a VPN service, has called some of its employees in for fresh job interviews. They are scheduled between 4 and 11 November, and the subject is how each person uses artificial intelligence in their work.
The email went out on Monday and was made public by the American outlet 404 Media, which obtained it. Its wording leaves little room for doubt. The interviews are "consequential". What comes out of them will be written up and fed into a broader review of the organisation that may lead to changes in "roles, responsibilities, and continued employment" — that is, in whether you still have a job.
Assessed by someone you don't work for
The interviews are not conducted by the employee's own manager. According to Tom's Guide and TechRadar, the interviewer comes from another part of the company, outside that person's reporting line, picked from leaders who "demonstrate strong AI capability". Chief executive Andy Yen started by talking to more than 40 leaders in engineering and product before the process was widened to the rest of the organisation.
Being able to name a few tools is not enough. Staff are expected to bring concrete examples: what they did, what came of it, and what did not work. Tech Times UK reports that the assessment also counts judgement — including knowing when not to use AI, for reasons of privacy, security or accuracy.
The company denies these are redundancies
Proton has answered the criticism in its own forum on Reddit: "Proton is not doing layoffs and using AI as an excuse." The company points to a shortage of qualified applicants, says it is still hiring, and that the interviews are meant to identify future leaders and those who need support. An invitation is not in itself a decision, the company writes; decisions about individuals will be communicated separately.
The two statements are hard to reconcile. The email talks about continued employment. The forum talks about recruitment.
The surveillance the company now lives with
The contradiction sharpens when you consider who is doing this. Proton was founded in 2014 on a promise that the contents of an email belong to the user and not to the provider. In August, Yen told Wired — as reported by both Tom's Guide and TechRadar — that he regards AI as a form of surveillance and would rather live in a world without it, but that the technology is here to stay. The company has since built a chatbot of its own, Lumo.
Proton is far from alone. TechRadar names Shopify, Duolingo, Meta and Google as companies that have turned AI use into a question of employment. In September, Meta dropped its dashboards tracking how much staff used the technology, because employees began gaming the system to look diligent.
Neither the company nor any of the sources says how many of Proton's staff have been called in. Nor how many people work there in total.
Sources
- Tom's Guide — that the internal email went out on Monday, that the interviews fall between 4 and 11 November, the "consequential" quote, that interviewers come from outside the employee's own team and reporting line and are drawn from leaders who "demonstrate strong AI capability", that Yen first spoke to more than 40 leaders in Engineering and Product, Proton's reply on Reddit, and the August Wired interview
- Tech Times UK — that 404 Media obtained the email and broke the story, that Proton is Swiss and was founded in 2014, that a list of tools is not enough, that judgement counts including knowing when AI should not be used, and the company's full Reddit quote
- TechRadar — the quote about "changes in roles, responsibilities, and continued employment", that Proton is behind the Lumo chatbot, Yen's remarks to Wired about AI as surveillance, and the comparison with Shopify, Duolingo, Meta and Google along with Meta's abandoned tracking of staff AI use